Showing posts with label learning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label learning. Show all posts

09 April 2010

Another Year, Another Test


For the past two years, I have been supporting teachers who have been preparing students to write the OSSLT. I have encountered the expected beligerance concerning the nature of standardized testing and how unfair and punitive it is. I have been shocked on occasion at the number of teachers who themselves have struggled to complete some of the tasks that students are asked to complete on the test, which according to my colleagues, tell us absolutely nothing about what students can do. I'm not quite so sure...

The OSSLT is a BASIC FUNCTIONAL LITERACY TEST. In fact, students should be able to complete it by the end of their grade 9 year. Granted, it is crafted in such a way that it isn't a total cake-walk. The instructions require students to read and re-read what is expected of them. The tasks themselves reflect work that students have been working on for the large majority of their academic career. The problem is that we don't teach our kids to name what they are doing. Admittedly, where the kids are disadvantaged is in the language of the test. What's particularly comical about that is that the test highly reflects the typical language of assessment in the Ontario classroom. Think about it: summarize, compare, list, describe, define, determine, explain your thinking, identify, justify, support your answer... I have often asked teachers, "do you teach your students EXPLICITLY what is expected of them when you asked them to do any of these tasks?" Typically, the response includes the assumptions that by grade 10, students should know what is expected of them. Do I really have address what happens when we assume? Let's face it, when it comes to preparing kids for this test, we spend more time blaming our colleagues in the elementary panel for not teaching the kids well enough instead of being accountable for our failure to be thorough enough in our on-going assessment, that is, if we ARE in fact assessing on an on-going basis. Another posting for another time...

As far as I'm concerned, this test demonstrates if our kids can read and write at a level where they can simply function in the world. Sometimes, the results force us to look really hard at what we are doing and NOT doing in our schools. Trust me, I know the limitations of analyzing this sort of statistical data. It does not present a complete picture. But our schools have those missing pieces. Our schools have access to attendance records and credit accumulation reports that can give some indication as to how some kids could potentially fare on this test. Instead of looking at the data after the fact, we should be using it to be proactive. The reality is that this test is not going anywhere. We can blame the previous administrations all we want about bringing this testing into the province but it seems that their predecessors don't have much of a problem with keeping it around. Funny, we never hear about that. I'll admit that I vote for Mike Harris. I liked how he thought and frankly I think he's been given a bum rap for the work he did in attempting to clean up a disaster area of a system. I'll take the heat for my politics, but I won't make excuses when kids can read and write at a basic level when they still manage to graduate from high school.

Yesterday, thousands of students across the province were dry-heaving inside while they wrote the OSSLT. My heart goes out to them, really. I appreciate the stress that goes along with writing this test. They're told that it's a high-stakes situation, and it's true. This is the one thing that technically stands in the way of graduation. I would assert, however, that the daily work in the classroom in becoming even more high-stakes. Again, another posting for another time...

27 October 2009

Full-Day Kindergarten Kinda Makes Sense...

I'm not entirely sold on Ontario's premier. I am, however, liking his idea to make kindergarten a full day more and more. He was recently quote as having said, "In a highly competitive, global knowledge-based economy it's absolutely essential that we invest in the younger generation to ensure that we build a powerful workforce that can compete and win against the best anywhere on this planet." I think he makes a good point. Research also shows that kids who attend full-day programs before grade one have better-developed social and academic (especially literacy and vocabulary) skills. In Ontario, kids get access to these kinds of programs if their parents can afford it. Full day kindergarten will level the playing field in terms of what young children have access to in their formative years.

I have to admit, this is tres gutsy, given the current economic climate. Anyone who is willing to present taxpayers with an annual bill for $1.5 billion has got my respect.

26 October 2009

iPods in Education ... iLike!




Skeptics of the world, hear me out... I know what you're all thinking. We don't need to give our kids yet another excuse not to pay attention in class. I know that this idea will take a little getting used to be it actually makes so much sense.

When I was at When Faith Meets Pedagogy on Friday, I attended a session called iTouch, iLearn. It was hosted by Rob Policicchio of Apple Canada. The focus of the presentation was how to incorporate iPods in education. He has been working with a number of schools who are using the various iPod products for a whole host of different reasons. Here are a few:

-audio books
-uploading tests with audio files for Special Ed. students to follow along
-video books
-podcasts - both teacher- and student-created
-assessing fluency in reading

If you think about it, the combination of viewing text and hearing increases retention and understanding. That's useful to ALL students, not just those who struggle at school.

Rob pointed out that iTunes (a free to download software), is loaded with free downloads for educators and has a wealth of audio books and podcasts that are appropriate for the classroom at both the elementary and secondary level. As well, there is a lot material for professional development for teachers (e.g. podcasts on how to podcast - I thought this was funny, but after further research, I learned that the number topic in podcasts in education is podcasts in education...).

Apple Canada is not paying me for this endorsement, but I couldn't help but add my two cents worth about this worth while opportunity that I think can be afforded to students.

18 August 2009

Marva Collins

I had no idea who this woman was before about 15 minutes ago. I was doing some research for a completely different project and came across some of her quotations and I can't remember the last time I reacted out loud to something I read on quotes website. Take a read...

“I have discovered few learning disabled students in my three decades of teaching. I have, however, discovered many, many victims of teaching inabilities.”


Marva Collins is an iconic American educator who started Westside Preparatory School in an impoverished neighborhood of Chicago. Unfortunately, the school closed down in 2008 after 30 years due to declining enrollment and funding. Collins championed the Socratic method. I've heard many a teacher poo-poo this method, but she saw true value in its use when it came to teaching those students who were deemed "unteachable". Her method is described as follows:

The first step is to select material with abstract content to challenge students' logic, and that will therefore have different meaning to different students, in order to aid discussion. This is done specifically to teach children to reason.

Next, the teacher should read the material, because unknown material cannot be taught. New words, the words to watch, should be listed, and taught, for pronunciation, use and spelling before the material is read. Without this step, the reading is meaningless.

Next, one begins a series of pertinent questions as the reading progresses, starting with a reference to the title, and a question about what the material is about. Predictions should use logic, reasoning and evidence without fallacy. The reading must be out loud, so the teacher can ask questions at pertinent points. Students are taught to test their reasoning. Afterward, they write daily letters to the author or characters, and write a critical review. Why is the work important to them? The child must be taught to refer to what was previously learned to support their opinions.

In the Socratic method, the rate of information is controlled by the teacher. Properly paced, this encourages participation, reducing discipline issues and encouraging self-discipline. The program specifically avoids work-sheets and inane busy work. It establishes an intellectual atmosphere, a general attitude suspending judgement, and examining reasoning.


(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marva_Collins)

I think the rationale for this method can summed up in another remark made by Collins:

“The essence of teaching is to make learning contagious, to have one idea spark another.”


It's time for a little introspection in education and whole lot less looking at standard test scores to diagnose what's wrong with our students. It's time to start asking what is wrong with us...

28 July 2009

What An Art Teacher Taught Me About Literacy

This is my dear friend, Rosemarie Gidaro. She is the head of Arts of St. Jean de Brebeuf CHS in our Board. I've known Rosemarie for about 13 years, since I was 17 and a student at another high school where she taught. I thought it was a great twist of fate that a former teacher would become a colleague from whom I would learn a great deal.



What I learned from Rose is the importance of self-authentification. She pushes students to be honest in their work so that their true voice emerges in their work, regardless of the medium they are working in or the subject matter. It seemed to me that this was most important and that skill would develop along the way so long as what the students were doing was meaningful and authentic to and for them. It's what keeps students engaged and motivated. When I had transitioned to the secondary panel, I think I got it all wrong. For me, skill was paramount and once there was a certain level of mastery, then students could use those skills in a variety of application. Even though she runs a very well-structured program, Rosemarie affords her students a great deal of freedom and it allows them to develop their voice, be it on canvas, in clay or through the lens of a camera. Skill is learned in context and the student voice is made more clear and precise along the way. Art is a highly metacognitive exercise and students obviously benefit from reflective and reflexive practices. It refines skills and instills a sense of pride in one's work. Surely, this is what we need to be doing across all areas of the curriculum as far as the teaching of literacy is concerned.

I have come to define literacy a little differently as far as the needs of the 21st century go. Literacy, I believe, is about interpreting and participating in a means of expression. Simple. Highly interpretive. I think these two points are critical for the kids we teach these days. Whether they go onto the study the arts at the post-secondary level, Rosemarie's students are quite proficient in their ability to talk not only about their work, but others' as well because of the deliberate emphasis of developing one's true voice as a vehicle for skill development. What is in demand in this marketplace are individuals who can be creative and original, making something new out of pre-existing knowledge. In order for anyone to be able to do that, one needs to have a firm grip on his or her authentic self and a refined and proficient use of skill, regardless of using a laptop computer, pen or paintbrush.

20 May 2009

Twittered and Unsure...



Anyone who knows me and understands me as an educator knows that I love to be current and relevant in the classroom, and this includes bringing in as much technology as possible when and where appropriate and learning all the up-and-coming Web 2.0 applications when time permits. I recently decided to learn how to use Twitter and I'm not sure that I'm all the impressed - yet. Granted, it's easy to use and it forces you to be succinct - only 140 characters per "tweet".

Here is where I can see it useful:

1. Class discussions and/or online seminars

2. Creation of community in a digital space

3. Instant feedback

4. A public forum to share thoughts, challenges and ideas

5. Building networking skills

6. An alternative to email

I especially like that Twitter can be accessed from a number of devices apart from the computer: iPhones, cell phones, smart devices and any Internet-enabled device.

Here is where I am not so smitten. In "mucking around" the site, I found that it is mostly social. People's "tweets" are for the most part, incosequential and irrelevant to me. I admit, at the moment, I am following some of my favourite bands to keep up to speed with concert listings and album releases. I'm also following Time magazine and a friend of mine. So I suppose that I'm using Twitter to satisfy personal needs, in which case, Twitter can be whatever you want it to be.

I came across a blog, teaching.mrbelshaw.co.uk. Doug Belshaw had this to say about using Twitter with students:

I think Twitter could be ideal for reminding students about homework, trips and such things, especially as they can enter their mobile phone number to be alerted when one of their ‘friends’ updates their account. The advantage is that you don’t need to know the phone numbers of students to get messages onto their device: they are the ones who authorize their mobile phone from the website and they subscribe to your Twitter feed.


Is this not just an updated version of the good ol' class website?

Carol Cooper-Taylor has some intersting ideas about using Twitter in education. She writes that Twitter is great for opinion polls. The first thing that comes to mind are anticipation guides. Why not throw out a question to gauge where students are at, how much they think they know and what they feel on a specific topic or issue? Another great idea she has is instead of answering the question, "What are you doing?" get students to answer "What has your attention?" This could be a terrific pre-writing activity - great for generating ideas (and the boys will certainly benefit from this). Finally, Twitter allows parents to see what's going on in the classroom. Everything is open and transparent - nothing wrong with that.

I think I'll muck around some more and wait to render my verdict. I'm all for using this in a classroom setting if it's effective and meaningful.

04 May 2009

Just how fast are we moving?

In an in-service on teaching literacy across the curriculum, my partner Cathie shared this anology with the group, and I thought it was so relevant and terrific:



60 minutes = 5000 years that people have had access to writing systems

On this scale, there were few significant media changes until about 7.5 mins ago -printing press came into use in Western culture.

2 minutes ago - - - the telegraph, photograph, and locomotive

1.5 minutes ago - - - telephone, phonograph, rotary press, motion pictures, automobile, airplane and radio

1 minute ago - - - talking picture

In the last 40 seconds - - - the TV

In the last 6 sec - - - the computer

Last few - satellites, laser beams, translation machines, interactive telecommunications, Internet, video games

We're always playing catch-up...

Are You Ready?

I'm learning more and more about the emergence of what is being called SPOT (Smart Personal Object Technology). It's the brainchild of Microsoft (no surprise there) to create software and hardware to personalize household electronics and everyday devices to make their uses more versatile. This includes everything from watches to coffee makers. Take a look:







Crazy, ain't it!! I just wonder how long before these sorts of gagets start appearing in our classrooms, and how ready we're going to be...

22 April 2009

Critical Literacy and Religion: An Androgynous Jesus?



How's this for an interesting lesson in critical literacy for religion teachers! I have never seen Christ rendered in any art form quite like this. The following excerpt comes from a website that deals with Christ iconography:
This image "Jesus of the People" by Janet McKenzie portrays Jesus as relatively androgynous and as black. Edwina Sandys' Christa portrays Jesus as a woman hanging on the cross, and was extremely controversial. Reinterpretations like these make the symbol of Jesus Christ accesible to people who do not wish to accept the traditional white European male image. Many feminists have chosen to reinterpret Christ, not visually but theoretically, and this is often labeled feminist christology.<(http://www2.kenyon.edu/Depts/Religion/Projects/Reln91/Gender/qchristology.htm)

This exercise is a great opportunity to look at conventional portrayals of Jesus and discuss why they were chosen or deemed acceptable? By whom? For what purpose? Are there any underlying issues of power that are implicated in certain portrayals of Christ? Why are most renderings of Christ reflect a man of northern European descent as opposed to Middle Eastern ancestry?

I would LOVE to hear what students have to say on this. I think this sort of activity is guaranteed to promote high levels of engagement because:
1.) it's inquiry based learning
2.)it involves a great deal of inductive reasoning (your boys will thank you)
3.)it's highly controversial - what teenager doesn't like to challenge the status
quo?
4.)students are doing all the meaning-making, while participating in highly academic
processes(research, synthesis, evaluation, etc.)

In the past, I have challenged my students to create their own artistic renderings of Jesus and the diversity is astounding. Their creations often reflect their own personal relationship with Jesus. I have often taught this sort of lesson in the context of discussing how the four gospels provide very distinct representations of who Jesus is (supported by an article called "The Four Faces of Jesus"). I have done this lesson with grade 10 students taking the Christ in Culture course. A sure winner!

17 April 2009

A Great Analogy



I think of our journey to transforming how we talk about teaching and learning literacy in the YCDSB in terms of the Medicine Wheel. The next couple of years will involve a lot of building and awareness, and no doubt there will be struggle. I think the greatest struggle will be in convincing teachers that they're already doing a lot of the good work that the Literacy Prism is promoting. Like with any initiative - whether it's new or a re-packaging and formalizing existing structures - there is bound to be initial resistance because people are afraid of what they don't know or are not comfortable with. I just thought I'd post this because when I came across this diagram, it so precisely represented what I was thinking about our progress to this point.

14 April 2009

More Rigor... More Relevance... It's Possible!




On April 6 and 7, while at the Pathways to Partnerships Conference at the Fern Resort in Orillia, I attended two keynote addresses given by Willard Daggett, president and co-founder of the International Centre for Leadership and Education. When I heard he was American, my instinctive anti-American flags went up. (It happens when you spend so much time studying Canadian history, law and politics...) The reason why I even write this is that I figured that I would have to contextualize what was being said along the way. Surprisingly, a lot of what he said made sense. For me, the most compelling part of the presentation came in the form of the Rigor and Relevance Model (above). What I love about this is that it is learning that is anchored in real-world situations. It's contextualized learning. For me, it works. This is how I've always taught. The challenge is getting "buy in" from those who aren't doing this. In order for this model to work, there needs to be a culture that supports change and Education as a profession doesn't quite make the grade where change is concerned. Change takes place in society 4 to 5 times faster than it does in Education. Generally speaking, change - from the time of pre-implementation to implementation - takes about 5-10 years, but in Education it's 35-50. Does this bother anyone else?

In the grand scheme of things, I was just relieved to know that the work being done to develop and craft the Literacy Prism was in line with a lot of mainstream thinking. Every so often, I wonder if this framework will be seen as something new, even though it's not. I wonder if teachers will be leary to accept it because it looks a little different, even though we have been promoting these beliefs for quite some time. The Prism promotes rigor and relevance across the curriculum. I hope it will be received this way...